What Is Problem Solving? Core Definition, Internal Actions, and a Practical Example
The four core actions that drive real-world problem solving—from pinpointing the reality-goal gap to closing it through iterative feedback.
Problem solving is the process of finding a solution to a problem. This will start once you recognize a gap between your current reality and your goal(s). From that point onward, problem solving involves a continuous cycle of defining the problem, breaking it down, thinking through potential solutions, taking action in the real world, and using objective feedback to improve your actions in order to reach your desired outcome.
Often people will refer to problem solving as coming up with a great idea. However problem solving isn’t purely brainstorming in your mind. Problem solving is a full process where you use your mind and then take action.
Deconstructing Problem Solving: The Time Span and Four Core Actions
We can identify what ‘problem solving’ truly means by splitting it into one time element, and 4 actions being performed within that time:
| Component Dimension | Core Element | Where It Happens | Essential Role in Problem Solving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time Span | Dynamic Process | Start to finish | The entire period from identifying a gap between the current reality and the desired outcome to achieving the desired outcome or objectively verifying an acceptable solution. |
| Action 1 | Problem Definition | Cognitive level | Answers “What is this problem, actually?” by pinpointing the exact gap between the current state and the desired goal. |
| Action 2 | Deconstruction | Cognitive level | Encompasses problem deconstruction (splitting sub-problems), variable deconstruction (isolating key factors), and interaction trade-offs (checking coupling between sub-problems). |
| Action 3 | Logical Thinking | Inside the mind | Running causal deductions in your head and invoking mental models (such as analyzing how to break the issue down or deriving an action plan). |
| Action 4 | Execution & Feedback Iteration | real-world application | Translating mental plans into real-world action, reading objective feedback, and either advancing if the gap shrinks or looping back to adjust until resolved. |
1. The Process: Clear Start and Finish
The problem-solving process is an evolving period of time that has both a beginning and end.
- The Starting Point: It begins at the point where you realise there is a disparity between what is and what should be.
- The Ending Point: The process ends once the desired outcome is met, or it can be objectively proven to have an acceptable solution. As long as there is a gap, you are still in the problem solving process.
2. The Actions: The four gears
Throughout that problem-solving process, a problem solver continuously cycles through the following four actions
Problem Definition: Everything stems from problem definition – “What is this problem, actually?” Here the problem is defined so that we can understand what we are working on. By defining the problem we can take a vague understanding of a problem and identify the gap between where we are now and where we want to be (this is the key part of problem formulation).
Deconstruction: If there is a large gap to fix, it needs to be broken down into manageable chunks. This can be done in three ways:
- Problem Deconstruction: Taking the large problem and breaking it into smaller, solvable sub-problems. In deterministic complicated problem the total of the sub-problems will equal the main problem.
- Variable Deconstruction: Identifying the key variables which affect the problem.
- Interaction (Complex Problems Only): Identifying if sub-problems are interacting or if the solution to sub-problem A will make sub-problem B worse.
Thinking: Using logical thinking and mental models. For example working out how to break down the problem or deducing how to take the broken down chunks and create a solution (e.g. creating a logic tree).
Execution and Feedback Cycle: This is where theory meets practice. It includes;
Conversion: Taking the theoretical solution and applying it in the real world.
Feedback: Seeing how the real world reacts to what we have done. If the real world shows us that we have reduced the gap between where we are now and where we want to be then we carry on. If it does not match our expectations we will go back and redefine the problem, look at the variables again or change our approach. We will repeat this until the problem is fully solved.
Example: a Jigsaw Puzzle
Let’s think about solving a jigsaw puzzle.
1. The Problem Emerges: The Gap Between Reality and Goal
When you open up the new box of jigsaw puzzle pieces, you have a bunch of jumbled up pieces on the table. This represents our current situation. However, we can see from the box lid that we want a complete picture. This is where the “problem.” is born! We will be using problem solving techniques from the point we decide to solve the puzzle.
2. Problem Deconstruction: Splitting the Macro-Goal
If we just look at the pile of pieces on the table we cannot solve the problem of “finish the whole picture” in one stroke. So we break down the problem into three distinct sub-problems:
- How to find and connect the four corner pieces.
- How to complete the border.
- How to fill in the middle.
3. Thinking and Mental Models: Reasoning Inside the Mind
Before reaching for a piece, our brain will start to logically think : We will decide which sub-problem we need to complete first. Do we find the four corners? Or do we just complete from one corner?
We will then begin to use some mental models. We will use:
- Top-down systematic decomposition. We will sort the pieces based on their colour groupings and flat edges so that we can complete the four sided border frame. This will give us a much smaller area to search.
- Bottom-up pattern recognition. We will look at the tabs, blanks and lines on the matched pieces to work out in our head what the next matching piece will look like.
4. Execution + Feedback:
This is the most important part of the definition. If you think to yourself, based on the colour and shape of the two pieces that they should fit together…
You need to actually do something. Reach out, take the pieces and try to match them up.
When you press them together…
You will receive real feedback from the physical forces acting on your fingers and how they match up:
- If they don’t interlock, feel stiff or just not match up you will know straight away from the real world that your hypothesis is incorrect. You will then need to disregard your hypothesis and move that piece away to try another one (Iterative correction).
- Only once you have gone through this cycle of forming a hypothesis in your mind, pressing the pieces together, using your fingers to get feedback and changing your approach until the last piece fits perfectly and the gap between the disorganised pile and the complete picture is zero will you have successfully solved the problem.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the exact definition of problem solving?
Problem solving is the act of finding a solution to a problem. From identifying there is an issue between where you are and the goal, problem solving is taking steps to define, break down, logically think and act in the real world whilst incorporating feedback.
Why isn’t coming up with a good idea in your head considered problem solving?
Because it is part of the process but it isn’t actually doing anything in the real world. Problem solving is when you have tested your hypothesis through real world actions.
When does the process of problem solving officially end?
It stops once you have achieved your desired outcome. Or when you’ve found a solution and can verify it works. Whilst there is still a gap between where you are and where you want to be, anything that happens along the way including breaking down the problem, planning and attempting will all be part of the process.
References
- LessWrong: Problem Solving with Mazes and Crayon
- UC Berkeley: What is Problem Solving?
- Wikipedia: Problem Solving